I have like 2 of these a year so I usually try to get something good.  A lot of times I end up getting something that ends up tasting like shit the next day, and pretty much regret my decision to do it in the first place for the next week or so as the Cigar's remains flush out of my throat and nasal cavities.  I did find a cigar I really like though; Rocky Patel Vintage 1992.  The sucker reminded me of a warm humidor smelling of redwood or something.  The next day I didn't have the terrible aftertaste but more of the same flavorful taste - almost made me want another days later.  I'm not much a smoker though, but I will remember this one the next time I have a hankering.

http://www.cigar.com/cigars/viewcigar.asp?brand=313&sourceid=CGWS02, http://www.whatsknottolove.com/cigars.php/72